To Hell and Back – recovering from hypothyroidism (a Dietitian’s Journey – Part II)

Last Monday, I went to the lab for updated blood work, including a thyroid hormone panel, additional thyroid antibody tests, and an iron panel. I have moved past the frustration of there being no pricelist available for consumers who are self-paying for lab tests, and am now focusing on the lab test results, and the dietary changes that I need to make in light of those, as I am recovering from hypothyroidism.


DISCLAIMER: This article is a personal account posted under A Dietitian’s Journey. The information in this post should in no way be taken as a recommendation to self-diagnose, self-interpret diagnostic tests, or self-treat any suspected disorder. It is essential that people who suspect they may have symptoms of any condition consult with their doctor, as only a medical doctor can diagnose and treat.


The results came back late Monday afternoon and I met with my doctor to discuss them on Thursday, The good news is that based on calculation estimates converting the bovine Natural Desiccated Thyroid (NDT) medication that I had been taking, to a mixture of Synthroid® (a synthetic T4 medication) and Cytomel® (a synthetic T3 medication), my free T4 and free T3 are almost perfect. As my doctor said when we met, “between your research and my experience, we got this“.

This is a beautiful picture.

TSH, fT4 and fT3 levels on T4/T3 thyroid hormone replacement medication

It shows, as my doctor and I had hoped, that my free T3 (the active thyroid hormone) is in the higher part of the reference range (65.5%); a level considered optimal by endocrinologists and thyroidologists who are well-versed in the use of the combination T4/T3 medications that I have been prescribed.

While my free T4 could be in the higher part of the range on the type of medication that I am taking, it may slightly lower because of the feedback from having sufficient free T3. That’s okay! I am feeling so much better, although it will take another year or more until I am really well again.

As expected, my TSH (Thyroid Stimulating Hormone, the pituitary hormone that tells the body how much thyroid hormone to make) is low because the amount of free T3 is optimal. This is a classic feedback loop where free T3 provides feedback on the pituitary gland, indicating that there isn’t a need to make more thyroid hormone. Think of it like a thermostat.  When the room gets warm enough, there is feedback on the thermostat that no additional heat is required, and it turns it off until the room gets cold again.

Of importance, my TSH is not considered “suppressed” (TSH ≤0.03 mU/L) but “low” (TSH = 0.04-0.4 mU/liter) [1], so there is no increased risk of cardiovascular disease or bone fractures. Those with a “high” TSH (>4.0 mU/liter) — which was the level that I was at before being treated, and those with a “suppressed” TSH (≤0.03 mU/L) both have an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, abnormal heart rhythms and bone fractures. Those with “low” TSH (0.04-0.4 mU/liter) like I have, do not [1,2]. So more good news.

I have been diagnosed with Hashimoto’s disease (also known as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis) which is an autoimmune disease and diagnosis is based both on symptoms of hypothyroidism, along with the presence of thyroperoxidase antibodies (TPO-ab) and thyroglobulin antibodies (TG-ab) in the blood [3].

In many cases of hypothyroidism, it is these antibodies that contribute to the gradual disappearance of thyroid cells and the development of hypothyroidism.  In my case, it was the trauma to the thyroid that resulted from surgery that I had 30 years ago to remove a benign tumour that was the major contributor to the eventual decrease in thyroid function.

Prior to being diagnosed, as you can read about here, I had all the classic symptoms of hypothyroidism, including body aches, joint pain, fatigue, feeling chilled, constipation, dry skin, hair loss, being forgetful, and even feeling depressed.

By the point I realized that these symptoms were not consistent with long-Covid (which is what I initially suspected) or aging (which my sons assumed), I had developed some of the symptoms of severe hypothyroidism [3], including difficulty with speech, significant water retention, and peripheral edema (swelling) of the ankles and face [3]. There are more photos of what I looked like when I was very sick here as well as photos from the beginning part of my recovery.


To hell and back – 5 months of recovery from hypothyroidism

The photo on the left, above is what I looked like on June 3, 2022, at my youngest son’s wedding.  I was so sick. I needed help walking on the beach for family photos, getting out of a chair or a car,  I ached all over my body and I was beyond exhausted.  I knew I was ill and had plans to see my doctor when he returned from vacation but in the meantime, I attended my son’s wedding, without talking about how I felt. No one really knew how sick I felt until afterwards and I didn’t know how seriously ill I really was until August.

The middle picture, above was taken on September 3, 2022 after losing half my hair as a result of several nutrient deficiencies related to hypothyroidism that I have been correcting through adding specific foods high in these nutrients into my diet, as well as highly bioavailable supplements.  At the time the middle picture was taken, I had been on Natural Desiccated Thyroid hormones (natural T4/T3 medication) for 6 weeks. While my doctor wanted me to continue on them because I was doing so much better, I wanted to go on synthetic T4 and T3 thyroid replacement hormones as it would be easier to travel across borders with these recognized medications.

The picture on the right, is me today.  I feel as though I have been to “hell and back“.  Last week, my doctor said that it will take another year until I feel really well again, and probably another 6 months on top of that until my hair grows back, but I am so thankful for the difference in how I feel the last 5 months. I get tired easily. Hiking is out, and so are evening activities, but as my nutrient status continues to improve and the thyroid hormones permeate all my body’s tissues, I will gradually feel better and better.


The blood tests confirm that I have both thyroperoxidase antibodies (TPO-Ab) and thyroglobulin antibodies (TG-Ab), which along with my symptoms, confirms my diagnosis of Hashimoto’s disease, but thankfully my blood test results indicate that neither are elevated.

Thyroperoxidase-Ab = 9 (<35 IU/mL)

Thyroglobulin Ab = 14 (<40 IU/mL)

While they are not elevated, they are present. 

Gliadin and Transglutaminase

For many years I avoided gluten containing products because I thought I was gluten intolerant, although not celiac.

A year ago that I stumbled across some novel ingredients and had an idea to create low carb breads to provide dietary options for those with diabetes. My goal was to enable people who would not otherwise consider a low carbohydrate diet to be able to adopt one, for health reasons.   I was mainly thinking of those from bread-centric cultures such as South East Asians (Indian) and Hispanics but in time, I developed many more types of low carb bread. 

I was aware of the connection between high gluten consumption and leaky gut syndrome, but against that I weighed the serious morbidity and mortality linked to uncontrolled diabetes. I had come across many people who would rather stay diabetic, and potentially lose their toes or vision than give up bread and developing these breads seemed like the lesser of two evils. 

Since being diagnosed with hypothyroidism that I had been developing over the previous 9 years (more about that here), I learned that the gliadin fraction of gluten structurally resembles transglutaminase. Transglutaminase is an enzyme that makes chemical bonds in the body, and while present in many organs, there are higher concentrations of transglutaminase in the thyroid.

In leaky gut syndrome, gliadin (and other  substances) result in the gaps in between the cells of the intestinal wall to widen. This results in the immune system of the body reacting to food particles that are inside the intestine, that it normally would not see. It is thought that the immune system reacts to gliadin and creates antibodies to it, seeing it as a foreign invader.  Since gliadin and transglutaminase have very similar structural properties, it is thought that in those with leaky gut syndrome, the immune system begins to attack the transglutaminase in the thyroid, and other tissues, contributing to the development of auto-immune conditions, including hypothyroidism

A-1 Beta Casein and Gluten

A few years ago, I had leaky gut syndrome but it resolved with dietary changes, including avoiding gluten and A-1 beta casein dairy (you can read about what A-1 beta casein dairy is here).  Naturally, as I had been working on recipe development for the low carb bread book, I had been eating gluten as I tested them. I also became more liberal in including dairy products from A1-beta casein cows, when I hadn’t used it in years. That started when there was severe flooding last year in Chilliwack last year due to heavy rains after the summer, and that was where my goat milk came from.  Even once the roads were open again and the highways rebuilt, I never really went back to using goat milk, which is naturally A-2 beta casein. In the interest of an abundance of caution, I will go back to using dairy products from A-2 beta casein cows, or from goat or sheep milk (that are naturally A-2). Humans produce A-2 beta casein protein, and using milk from A-2 beta casein animals does not result in an immune response. It is not seen as “foreign.”

From what I’ve read and in discussing it with my doctor, it is likely that my hypothyroidism has been developing over the last 30 years, related to the surgery I had to remove a benign tumour. Further supporting that me becoming hypothyroid has been a long time in the making, I have had high-normal levels of TSH over the last 9 years — which happens to be a time period over which I was avoiding both gluten and A-1 dairy. Given that, I think it’s logical to conclude that my hypothyroidism is primarily related to the destruction of thyroid tissue in the invasive surgery connected to removal of the tumour. Further supporting this hypothesis, I currently have fairly low levels of TPO and TG antibodies, so I suspect they have begun developing fairly recently. Since a 2018 study reported that  both TPO-antibodies and TG antibodies are decreased in hypothyroid patients following a gluten-free diet [4], it seems wise for me to go back to avoiding gluten, with the goal of lowering my TPO-antibodies and TG-antibodies down to as close to zero, as possible.

Cruciferous Vegetables

Cruciferous vegetables such as Brussels sprouts, broccoli, bok choy, cauliflower, cabbage, kale are known goitrogens. Goitrogens are naturally occurring substances that are thought to inhibit thyroid hormone production. The hydrolysis of a substance known as pro-goitrin that is found in cruciferous vegetables produces a substance known as goitrin, that is thought to interfere with thyroid hormone synthesis [5]. Since cooking cruciferous vegetables limits the effect on the thyroid function, and eating cruciferous vegetables have many health benefits, I will usually eat them cooked, but not in huge quantities. There are studies that found a worsening of hypothyroidism when people ate very large quantities of these (e.g. 1 – 1 ½ kg / day) so it is recommended that intake of these vegetables be kept relatively constant day to day, and limited to no more than 1-2 cup / day. I’ve decided that when I do eat them, to keep intake to the lower end of that range, and eat more non-cruciferous vegetables instead.

Iron Deficiency and Low Stomach Acid (hypochlorhydria)

I now know why I am still so tired. I asked my doctor to run an iron panel and the results show I have low iron. Previous results indicate my vitamin B12 are fine and I continue to supplement methylated folate and B12, so I know those are not a problem.

While my iron stores (ferritin) are okay, they are not optimal i.e., ferritin = 93 (15-247 ug/L) instead of >100ug/L.

My hematology panel is low-normal i.e. hemoglobin = 122 (115-155 g/L), hematocrit = 0.37* (0.35-0.45 L/L), MCV = 88 (82-98 fl), MCH = 29.5 (27.5-33.5 pg), MCHC = 334 (300-370 g/L)

My serum iron and iron saturation are very low i.e., serum iron = 11.9 (10.6-33.8 umol/L), iron saturation = 0.15 (0.13-0.50)

Low iron status is common with hypothyroidism, but it was surprising to me because I eat beef liver, or chicken livers every week, and also take a heme polysaccharide supplement (like Feramax®), so it may be due to an absorption problem.

Low stomach acid (hypochlorhydria) is common in hypothyroidism, and since low pH is needed for iron absorption, I have made dietary changes to improve that.

Final Thoughts…

I am very grateful that my doctor recognizes my knowledge as a clinician and is receptive to me advocating for my health. I am incredibly fortunate that he involves me in decisions regarding blood tests, as well as discussing medication types and dosages.  As for the dietary changes and supplementation, he is content to let me handle that!

I hope that out of my experience that I have called “to hell and back” that I am able to help others better understand hypothyroid symptoms, diagnosis and treatment options so that they can discuss them with their doctor.

To your good health,

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

Articles about Hypothyroidism

References

  1. van Vliet NA, Noordam R, van Klinken JB, et al. Thyroid Stimulating Hormone and Bone Mineral Density: Evidence From a Two-Sample Mendelian Randomization Study and a Candidate Gene Association Study. J Bone Miner Res. 2018;33(7):1318-1325. doi:10.1002/jbmr.3426
  2. Flynn RW, Bonellie SR, Jung RT, MacDonald TM, Morris AD, Leese GP. Serum thyroid-stimulating hormone concentration and morbidity from cardiovascular disease and fractures in patients on long-term thyroxine therapy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95(1):186-193. doi:10.1210/jc.2009-1625
  3. Puszkarz, Irena, Guty, Edyta, Stefaniak, Iwona, & Bonarek, Aleksandra. (2018). Role of food and nutrition in pathogenesis and prevention of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1320419
  4. Krysiak, R.; Szkróbka, W.; Okopień, B. The Effect of Gluten-Free Diet on Thyroid Autoimmunity in Drug-Naïve Women with Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis: A Pilot Study. Exp. Clin. Endocrinol. Diabetes 2018, 127, 417–422.
  5.  Felker P, Bunch R, Leung AM. Concentrations of thiocyanate and goitrin in human plasma, their precursor concentrations in brassica vegetables, and associated potential risk for hypothyroidism. Nutr Rev. 2016;74(4):248-258.

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

Blood Tests and Lab Frustrations – a Dietitian’s Journey Part II

NOTICE: This my personal experience as a private consumer of lab services, and is not related to my profession as a Dietitian. This article is posted in a separate section of the web page titled “A Dietitian’s Journey” which is about my personal health journeys.

“A Dietitian’s Journey – Part I” was about my two year journey recovering from obesity, and poor metabolic health and “A Dietitian’s Journey-Part II” is my current  personal journey recovering from hypothyroidism.

This article is written as a private consumer, which is why it is categorized as a personal account, and an editorial.


This past Monday, I went to the lab to have blood tests to measure my thyroid hormones, anti-thyroid antibodies, and an iron panel. When I had met with my doctor last week, I learned that I would need to pay for the free T3 test because the British Columbia guidelines and protocols for ordering thyroid tests state that a free T3 test is only covered to rule out suspected cases of hyperthyroidism [1]. As I wrote last Thursday, I was “more than willing to pay for a $9.35 test to have all the data.” 

I think most people are aware that the healthcare system is economically stretched, and I certainly understand and accept the need to reduce costs. One way to do that is to restrict the ordering of laboratory tests to only medically justifiable circumstances, which makes good sense. 

While I recognize that I am not objective in this situation, it would seem to me that when someone is on thyroid hormone replacement medication that includes both synthetic T4 and T3 hormones, that the expense of both a free T4 test and free T3 test should be covered by the provincial healthcare system as the cost is justifiable because the prescribing doctor needs to determine if the dosage of both synthetic hormones is adequate, but not too high. 

As I said above, I knew last week that I would be paying for the free T3 test and was fine with that, but what I wasn’t prepared for was that I would be expected to pay three times the cost the government pays for the same test, and that there would no patient-price list available.

When I arrived at the lab on Monday, I was told that the free T3 test would cost $32.00.  I replied that there must be a mistake, because the cost of the test is $9.35. I was informed that the government pays $9.35 for the free T3 test, but the patient-pay cost for the same test is $32.00I explained to the person at the desk that I could understand the test costing more if there was a set-up fee for a stand-alone test, or for a separate blood draw, but this test was going to be run with others using the same blood draw.  I was informed that $32.00 is the patient-pay cost of the free T3 test regardless of whether it is done with other tests, or by itself.

I asked if I could please see the price list with the patient-pay costs, and was told that there isn’t one. I was asked if I wanted to have the free T3 test period formed, and if I did that I would need to pay $32.00. What choice did I have?  It was not as though I could go to one of the lab’s competitors, as this private lab company is the only one providing laboratory services in this city. 

[NOTE (October 28, 2022: I have spoken to people in other provinces, and it appears from what people have said that the practice of diagnostic laboratories not disclosing patient-pay prices occurs in Manitoba, Ontario, and British Columbia. This practice may also occur in others provinces as well, but I don’t know. This article written as private consumer is about the practice of diagnostic labs not disclosing patient-pay prices to consumers, irrespective of which province the practice occurs in, or by what company.]

I paid the $32.00 for the test because I needed this information to know the effect of the medication on my thyroid hormones, and for my doctor to know whether a medication adjustment was needed. I had the disposable income to pay for it, but what about consumers who need a laboratory test to make health decisions or for their doctor to be able to, and who cannot afford that? 

… and why are patient-pay clients charged 3 times as much as the government pays for the same test?  Even if a private consumer was only requesting a stand-alone test and had to pay the ~$15 blood draw fee, this test would only cost $25, not $32.

After my appointment, I wrote the regional office of the lab company and asked “to have the patient-pay lab prices for British Columbia.” I heard back from a Client Service Advisor who told me that “We do not provide a list of what we charge to patients“.

I was flabbergasted. 

I’ve always made the assumption that private businesses are required to post their prices, or at least make them available when asked.

As an individual consumer, what happened at the lab would be like going to the grocery store to buy food, but none of the items for sale have marked prices. You are required to pick out the things you need, but only find out at the cash register what the price is. 

When you get to the cash, you ask the cashier about the prices, and she tells you there’s no price list,  but she can give you the total cost at the end, and you can either pay, or put the items back. Needing the items, you pay what you are told, and take your receipt.

When you get home, you decide to write the head office and ask if they can send you a price list, and are told there IS one, but that they can’t give it to you.

[UPDATE October 29, 2022: The way things are currently set up, one has to make an appointment with the lab, go there, line up and give the person at the desk their requisition, and only then can find out how much the patient-pay part will cost.

After investing so much time, consumers are put in a position of having to make a decision on the spot — pay whatever is being asked, or leave without the test.

Consumers should be able to access the prices online and make a decision at their leisure, before investing so much time.] 

I don’t know whether private businesses in Canada required to post their prices, or make them available when asked. I’ve always assumed they were, but I could be wrong. If there is a requirement to do so, do diagnostic labs have an exemption that enables them not to make their prices available to members of the public?


UPDATE October 28, 2022: I have since found out the same company provides a price list to allied health professionals so that they can provide laboratory assessment services to their clients, and if they choose they can mark up the cost in their own billing.

There are 2 versions of this test list available. They are identical except the one for British Columbia does not have the prices indicated, whereas the Ontario one does (see below).

I have also since found out that the company DOES have patient-pay price list that is titled “British Columbia Private Price List for Commonly Ordered Lab Tests” and is dated April 2021. It is marked “confidential” and as a result cannot be publicly shared.  See #3, below.

        1. The allied healthcare price list available in Ontario, dated November 2018 has the prices marked. I have removed the company’s identifying colours, logo, and information and posted their allied health professional test list here.
        2. The allied healthcare price list available in British Columbia, dated June 2020 does not have the prices marked. I have likewise removed the company’s identifying colours, logo and information and have posted their allied health professional test list here. 

 

Above is the allied health professional cost (November 2018) for an entire thyroid panel of 6 thyroid-related lab tests, including;

          • TSH
          • free T4
          • free T3
          • reverse T3
          • thyroperoxidase antibody (TPO)
          • anti-thyroglobin antibody (TG-ab)

Compared to what the BC government pays for the same tests (minus the reverhttp://from http://www.bccss.org/bcaplm-site/Documents/Programs/laboratory_services_schedule_of_fees.pdfse T3 which isn’t paid for by MSP) the above panel costs $80. Presumably naturopaths are charged prices similar to what MSP pays.

3. I have since found out that there IS a patient-pay price list and it is titled “British Columbia Private Price List for Commonly Ordered Lab Tests” and is dated April 2021.

The prices cannot be posted because the notice at the top of the price list reads;

This is a confidential document. Please do not disclose our prices publicly except in conversations with your patients.”

Why is the private-pay price of lab tests a confidential document, and why can’t the prices of lab tests be disclosed to the public?

Are business in British Columbia required to disclosed their prices and if so, are diagnostic labs exempt from making their private-pay prices available to consumers?

I don’t know.

How many people would be willing to order dinner at a restaurant that did not post the price of its menu items until after they ordered?

 


My Thoughts on Patient-Pay Prices

I believe that as consumers, private-pay individuals have a right to have access to the prices for laboratory tests in advance, so that they can consider their decision to purchase, or not purchase these services. Consumers expect grocery stores and department stores to post their prices, and it is my personal opinion that privately owned laboratories from whom private consumers purchase services should be no different.

I also think private-pay individuals have a right to know why they are required to pay a premium price for the same services that the government gets for a third the cost, and allied healthcare professionals obtain for approximately half the cost.

This differential pricing for allied health professionals is a little like retailers selling supplements to practitioners at wholesale prices, while expecting the consumer to pay full price. Even car dealerships have “employee pricing” events so that the average consumer can take advantage of the same discounts provided to their employees, but at these diagnostic labs, consumers are unable to know in advance how much they will be paying for services before they arrive at the cash.

I believe that as private businesses, diagnostic laboratories are free to set their prices as they see fit but it would seem that (1) consumers should be able to know what those prices are in advance, and (2) that consumers should also know that they are paying a premium price for the same services, compared to what the government and allied health professionals are paying.


I am very grateful to live in a country where publicly funded medical care is available. I am thankful to have access to excellent diagnostic lab tests, and don’t even mind paying the same cost the government pays for tests that I want to have done. But as a private consumer, I believe the cost of services need to be available and that there needs to be transparency with regards to pricing discounts provided to others.

To your good health,

Joy

References

  1. BC Guidelines & Protocols Advisory Committee, Thyroid Function Testing in the Diagnosis and Monitoring of Thyroid Function Disorder, October 24, 2018

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

 

How to Watch the “Let’s End Diabetes” Sessions for Free

Yesterday (October 22, 2022), I was the Dietitian representing low carb and keto diets in the management of type 2 diabetes at the Diabetes Canada Let’s End Diabetes Virtual Conference. I co-presented with two other Dietitians; Jenna Walsh, RD, CDE who represented intermittent fasting, and Alka Chopra, RD, CDE who represented a plant-based approach.

I had hoped to be able to be able to post a link to the talk so that people could watch it, but that wasn’t possible. It also could not be downloaded and posted, so I made it as easy as possible for those who want to watch the talk to be able to do so.

 

 

Anyone can register for FREE on the Diabetes Canada website and watch any of the sessions (including the one I was in), but since some people had difficulty navigating the site yesterday, I am posting step-by-step directions here, including

(1) registering for the Diabetes Canada “Let’s End Diabetes” Conference for free
(2) finding to the “auditorium”
(3) entering the auditorium, and
(4) selecting the session you would like to watch (with the one I was in, as an example).

To make it easier, you can download a pdf of these same steps, with the links in them — so all you need to do is click on them.

I hope you find this helpful.

How to Register and Watch Diabetes Canada’s “Let’s End Diabetes” Sessions

 

(1) to register for the Diabetes Canada “Let’s End Diabetes” Conference for FREE, click here and select “register”.

(2) once you have completed your registration, find theauditorium” (see Step 2, below) and click on it (you will be brought here).

(3) Once you click on the link, you will be brought into the “auditorium”. On the screen, you will see “click here to view sessions (where circled in red, below).

(4) You will be brought here and see a list of all the sessions available.  To watch “Ask the Dietitian; Demystifying Popular Eating Patterns“, scroll down to the last session and click “play”.

More Info about Me

If you would like more information about how I can support you following a low carbohydrate of very low carbohydrate diet, please have a look under the Services tab, or send me a note through the Contact Me form.

To your good health!

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

Six-Week Follow-Up Doctor Visit – a Dietitian’s Journey

This morning I met with my doctor for my 6-week follow-up appointment to review my ongoing hypothyroid symptoms, current T4 & T3 medication dosages, and to discuss additional blood work to see how my body is responding to medication, as well as nutrient supplementation. I continue to be in awe of how cooperative my doctor is being! I am very well aware how many people with hypothyroidism do NOT get this kind of support from their doctors! I am very thankful.

My doctor agreed to my request for a thyroid panel [TSH, free T4, and free T3] even though I may have to pay for FT3 because of the provincial guidelines.

In British Columbia, free T3 testing is only available for those with suspected hyperthyroidism, not to assess levels of T3 as a result of thyroid hormone replacement medication. I am more than willing to pay for a $9.35 test [1] to have all the data.

I will also be having a full iron panel to see how my body is responding to nutrient supplementation , as iron status tends to be low in those with hypothyroidism. I have already had blood tests for other nutrients of concern in hypothyroidism, as well as for those I have been supplementing.

My doctor even ordered a thyroglobulin antibody (TG-ab) test, even though TPO antibodies for Hashimoto’s were negative. Interestingly, he thinks as do I that it is prudent to assume a Hashimoto’s diagnosis even in the absence of antibodies and act accordingly when it comes to diet and increased risk of other auto-immune disorders.

This coming Monday, I am going for my blood tests and should have the results back in 24-48 hours and am meeting with my doctor again next Thursday to go over the results, and consider medication dosage adjustment.

I am very grateful to be able to work with my doctor to advocate for my health, to be involved in the decision regarding blood tests, as well as discussing together medication adjustment.

I hope that out of my experience navigating my own care related to hypothyroidism, to better be able to help others advocate for themselves in this area.

To your good health,

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

Articles about Hypothyroidism

References

  1. BC Guidelines & Protocols Advisory Committee, Thyroid Function Testing in the Diagnosis and Monitoring of Thyroid Function Disorder, October 24, 2018

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

 

What Does Success Looks Like Now – A Dietitian’s Journey II

This article is the fourth entry in A Dietitian’s Journey Part II, which began with my recent diagnosis of hypothyroidism. This post is about how I will measure success as I recover from hypothyroidism.

NOTE: Articles posted under A Dietitian’s  Journey are separate from referenced clinical articles (categorized as Science Made Simple articles) because these are about what happened to me (i.e., anecdotal) and based on my personal observation.

A Dietitian’s Journey – Part I

What “success” looked like after the first A Dietitian’s Journey

“A Dietitian’s Journey” (Part I) was my personal weight-loss and health-recovery journey that began on March 5, 2017 when I decided to make dietary and lifestyle changes so that I could reclaim my health. At that time, I was obese, had type 2 diabetes for the previous 8 years, and extremely high blood pressure. 

Two years later, on March 5, 2019, I accomplished all but one of my goals, and the last one I achieved three months later. In all, I lost 55 pounds and more than a foot off my waist, and met the criteria for partial remission of type 2 diabetes, and remission of hypertension (high blood pressure).

To get an idea of what I looked like at the beginning and the end of that journey, there are two short videos on my Two Year Anniversary post that tell the story well.  The first video was taken when I started and it is very apparent how obese I was, and how difficult it was for me to walk and talk at the same time. The second clip was taken when I completed my journey, and the difference is unmistakable.  

A Dietitian’s Journey – Part II

Without much difficulty I maintained my health and my weight-loss from March 2019 until August 2020 but then I came down with Covid.  This was at the very beginning of the pandemic and no one really knew what to expect in terms of symptoms. As you can read about in the first post in what has become A Dietitian’s Journey Part II, (When a New Diagnosis is a Long Time Coming ) I had symptoms that both my doctor and I assumed were related to the virus, including muscle aches and joint pain, being exhausted, having ‘brain fog,’ headaches, and having the shivers.

Afterwards, I had to work very hard to regain my mobility. No one knew this wasn’t ‘normal.’

At first, I could barely walk up a flight of stairs. At the time, “success” was being able to walk around the block.  Then I began taking several dietary supplements to help strengthen my immune system and in retrospect, the reason I felt better was likely due to the fact that these were all supplements involved in thyroid support. Success at the time was being able to walk around the man-made lake at the local park, but over the weeks and months of supplementing my diet and walking every weekend, success was being able to complete several medium difficulty hikes in the local mountains. 

Unfortunately, in March of 2022,  I came down with what my doctor assumed was Covid again. At first the symptoms were similar to what I experienced in August 2020, including muscle aches, joint pain, being exhausted, feeling cold all the time, with the only difference being that I didn’t have headaches. The symptoms persisted for several months and I was beginning to think that I had “long-Covid.” As most people did over the pandemic, I put on 20 pounds, but from March to May, I began to look as though I was putting on significant weight, but every time I got on the scale it indicated only a few pounds of difference. I had no idea what was going on.

The next symptom that I became aware of was swelling in my ankles. It wasn’t just a little bit of swelling, but significant enough that I needed to wear compression stockings all day.

At my youngest son’s wedding at the beginning of June, I looked like I did when I was 55 pounds heavier, but I wasn’t.

LEFT: March 5, 2017, RIGHT: June 3, 2022

About three weeks after the wedding, I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism, and started taking desiccated thyroid. At first, I felt significantly better, and within several weeks, the edema in my legs began to subside.

There is still a fair amount of mucin accumulation in my legs, but as of this weekend, I can begin to grab a very small amount of flesh between my fingers. From what I have read it will take at least 6 months for this to resolve. You can read a referenced article about the skin symptoms associated with hypothyroidism here.

It is easy to see from the above photo that in less than 3 months on thyroid medication treatment, my face has lost its puffy, “inflated” look yet amidst the positive improvements of decreased edema and looking more like myself in some respects is the reality that I have lost ~1/2 of my hair due to telogen effluvium that often occurs with sustained hypothyroidism. You can read more different causes for hair loss here.

Loss of half my hair in 3 months due to telogen effluvium.

Even though I have already been on thyroid replacement hormones for several months, it usually takes ~3-6 months for hair loss to stop and another 3-6 months for regrowth to be seen and 12-18 months to complete regrowth [3]For someone like my who has lost half their hair, six months to a year to begin to see hair growth can seem like an eternity.

I recently changed medication forms from desiccated thyroid to a mixture of T4 medication (Synthroid®) and T3 medication (Cytomel®). The overall distribution of T4:T3 is about the same, but it is hoped that this mixture will result in more stable thyroid hormones day-to-day.

In six weeks I will have new blood tests to re-evaluate whether my levels have improved.  At last check, my TSH was still high-normal (3.47 mU/L) when in most patients on thyroid hormone replacement the goal TSH level is between 0.5 to 2.5 mU/L [7]My Free T4 =  14.0 pmol/L which is still in the lower end of the range (10.6-19.7 pmol/L) when it is considered optimal to be in the higher end of the range. 

Metabolic Changes due to Hypothyroidism

It’s well known that people with hypothyroidism experience several clinical changes including different type of anemia, changes in how their heart functions, changes in blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol and weight gain due to a slower metabolism. My recent medical work up indicates that I was no different in this regard.

Different Types of Anemia

People with hypothyroidism have a decrease in red blood cells and experience different types of anemia, including the anemia of chronic disease. In addition, 10% of people with hypothyroidism develop pernicious anemia, which is associated with vitamin B12 and folate (folic acid). Iron deficient anemia is also common due to decreased stomach acid that results in decreased absorption of iron.

I was supplementing with B12 and folate and as a result have no signs of pernicious anemia, however my hematology panel indicates that I may have iron deficient anemia. An iron panel would be able to quantify this, however I am already taking heme iron supplements, along with vitamin C to support absorption.

Heart Changes

The slowing of metabolism associated with hypothyroidism also results in a decrease in cardiac (heart) output, which results in both slower heart rate and less ability for the heart to pump blood.  This is what results in the unbearable fatigue.

High Blood Pressure

The decreased ability of the heart to pump leads to increased resistance in the blood vessels, which results in increased blood pressure (hypertension).

In those who had normal blood pressure previous to developing hypothyroidism, blood pressure can rise as high as 150/100 mmHg. Hypothyroidism may increase it further for those previously diagnosed with high blood pressure. While my blood pressure had been normal for more than a year, it gradually started increasing the last year, which in retrospect is the period of time over which I was exhibiting more and more symptoms of hypothyroidism. I have since been put back on medication for hypertension to protect my kidneys, which I hope to be able to get off of again within the next six month to a year, as my thyroid hormones normalize.

Weight Gain

Thyroid hormones act on every organ system in the body, but the thyroid is well-known for its role in energy metabolism. When someone has overt hypothyroidism, there is a slowing of metabolic processes, which results in symptoms such as fatigue, cold intolerance, constipation, and weight gain. 

Weight gain is not only about diet or how much someone eats versus how much they burn off. It is also about the person’s metabolic rate, which can be impacted by several things, including decreased thyroid hormones. I gained 20 pounds over the pandemic (much of which overlaps with the period of time over which I was exhibiting more and more symptoms of hypothyroidism. I also gained 10 pounds from March to June which is mostly water weight, due to the mucin accumulation.

High Cholesterol

It has long been known that those with hypothyroidism have high total cholesterol, high low-density lipoproteins (LDL) [4], and high triglycerides (TG) [5], which results from a decrease in the rate of cholesterol metabolism. My doctor deliberately did not want to check these last time, because he knew they would be abnormal only as a result of the hypothyroidism. He plans to evaluate them once I have been stable on hormone replacement for several months.

So, What Does Success Look Like Now?

Just as I had a clear idea of what success looked like in my first A Dietitian’s Journey, I have a clear idea of what I would like success to look like this time, as I recover from my hypothyroid diagnosis.

Over the next year, this is what I want to accomplish;

    1. weight same as March 5, 2019 (end of A Dietitian’s Journey, part I)
    2. waist circumference same as March 5, 2019 (end of A Dietitian’s Journey, part I)
    3. regrowth of my hair to same thickness as before clinical symptoms of hypothyroidism
    4. restoration of iron deficient anemia:
      (a) normal ferritin 11-307 ug/L
      (b) iron 10.6-33.8 umol/L
      (c) TIBC 45–81 µmol/L
      (d) transferrin  2.00-4.00 g/L
    5. Blood pressure ≤  130/80 mmHg
    6. Blood sugar:
      (a) non-diabetic range fasting blood glucose ≤  5.5 mmol/L
      (b) non-diabetic range HbA1C ≤  5.9 %
    7. Thyroid Hormones:
      (a) optimal TSH= 0.5 to 2.5 mU/L
      (b) optimal Free T4 = 15-18 pmol/L (10.6-19.7 pmol/L)
    8. Cholesterol:
      (a) LDL ≤ 1.5 mmol/L
      (b) TG ≤ 2.21 mmol/L

Final Thoughts…

While I don’t know if it will be possible to achieve all of these within the time frame or within adjustments to medication that my doctor will be willing to make, these are my goals. I believe that most of these are possible, and as far as they are within my control, this is what I would like to accomplish.

I have achieved a lot the last 3 months, but I am not “done.” I want the rest of my life back!

I want to be able to do the things that I enjoy, and to have the freedom to make plans in the evening knowing I will have the energy to follow through.

I think this is reasonable to ask and I will do everything I can to make this a reality.

A Dietitian’s Journey Part II continues…

To your good health,

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

References

  1. Rotondi M et al. Serum negative autoimmune thyroiditis displays a milder clinical picture compared with classic Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. Eur J Endocrinol 2014;171:31-6. Epub April 17 2014
  2. Croce, L., De Martinis, L., Pinto, S. et al. Compared with classic Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, chronic autoimmune serum-negative thyroiditis requires a lower substitution dose of L-thyroxine to correct hypothyroidism. J Endocrinol Invest 43, 1631–1636 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40618-020-01249-x
  3. Malkud S. Telogen Effluvium: A Review. J Clin Diagn Res. 2015;9(9):WE01-WE3. doi:10.7860/JCDR/2015/15219.6492
  4. Lithell, H., Boberg, J., Hellsing, K., Ljunghall, S., Lundqvist, G., Vessby, B., & Wide, L. (1981). Serum lipoprotein and apolipoprotein concentrations and tissue lipoprotein-lipase activity in overt and subclinical hypothyroidism: the effect of substitution therapy. European journal of clinical investigation11(1), 3–10. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2362.1981.tb01758.x
  5. Nikkila E, Kekki M, Plasma triglyceride metabolism in thyroid disease, J Clin Invest. 1973;51:203. 
  6. Iron Disorders Institute, Iron Deficiency, Understanding Iron Deficiency Anemia, http://irondisorders.org/iron-deficiency-anemia/
  7. American Thyroid Association, Is the TSH (thyroid stimulating hormone) a good way to titrate my thyroid hormone therapy? https://www.thyroid.org/patient-thyroid-information/what-are-thyroid-problems/q-and-a-tsh-thyroid-stimulating-hormone/

DISCLAIMER: The information in this post should not be taken as a recommendation to self-diagnose, self-interpret diagnostic tests, or self-treat any suspected disorder. It is essential that people who suspect they may have symptoms of any condition consult with their doctor, as only a medical doctor can diagnose and treat.

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

 

Judging By Appearance – a Dietitian’s Journey

We form an opinion about someone’s appearance when we haven’t seen them in a while, or meet them for the first time. We do so unintentionally, but we judge by appearance. Sometimes the appearance of weight gain is not about diet but a diagnosis. 

DISCLAIMER: (August 28, 2022): This article a personal account posted under A Dietitian’s Journey. The information in this post should in no way be taken as a recommendation to self-diagnose, self-interpret diagnostic tests, or self-treat any suspected disorder. It is essential that people who suspect they may have symptoms of any condition consult with their doctor, as only a medical doctor can diagnose and treat.

The photos below are both of me. On the left is what I looked like when I began my personal weight-loss and health-recovery journey on March 5, 2017. Over the following two years, I lost 55 pounds and 12 ½ inches off my waist following a low carb, and then a ketogenic diet. The process was slow — agonizingly slow and in retrospect, I now know why. The photo on the right is what I looked like two years later, maintaining my weight loss.

LEFT: March 5, 2017 RIGHT: December 2021 – after two years weight maintenance

Almost imperceptibly, my appearance began to change.  I didn’t “see it” at the time, but I was aware that my waist circumference was different and that my clothes felt tighter. What I couldn’t understand was that I had only “gained” approximately five pounds.

The two photos below clearly show the subtle difference.

LEFT: Hiking March 5, 2021, RIGHT: Hiking March 5, 2022

The photo on the left was taken on the two-year anniversary of completion of my weight loss journey which lasted from March 5, 2017-March 5, 2019 (documented under A Dietitian’s Journey). This entry in that journal which is titled From the Mountains Through the Valleys was written for my fifth anniversary, the day before the photo on the right.

The photo on the right was taken this past year in March, exactly one year after the photo on the left.  The comparison is easy because I was wearing the same clothes. While my weight was only approximately five pounds greater than on the left, it is clear to see that my face was puffier, as were my legs.  I remember getting dressed that morning and wondering why all my hiking clothes felt so tight. I also vividly remember how difficult the hike was that day — and it was a simple one with very little elevation. My legs felt heavy, and it was hard to walk up even the gentlest of inclines.

Despite having both vaccines in April 2021 and July 2021, a few days later I came down with what my doctor and I presumed was my second case of Covid-19.

I had Covid the first time in August 2020 and wrote about it in the journey entry titled, To Covid and Back).  In retrospect, I think the ‘post-viral arthritis’ I experienced afterwards may have been linked to my thyroid’s response to the virus (documented in the literature). In that post, I wrote about recovering from Covid the first time;

“By the end of August (after Covid) it was difficult for me to even walk up (or down!) a flight of stairs. This both shocked and scared me.

I began to go for walks — even though it was very hard.  At first they were literally just around the block, but I kept at it.  One of my young adult sons who lives with me kept encouraging me to walk, and would sometimes go with me.  As my legs became stronger, walks turned into short  inadvertent hikes’ and I discovered I really liked being out in the woods, even though it remained very hard to step up onto rocks, or step down from them.  I dug out the wood hiking staff that I brought with me when I moved from California and put it into service., invested in some hiking boots and other essentials’. As I said in the previous article, my hiking stick — along with my fuchsia rain gear has become somewhat of an identifier— but the truth is, without the hiking stick, I could not have possibly begun to hike.

My first breakthrough was in late November, when I did my 4th real hike which was 12 km around Buntzen Lake — which in terms of a few elevation gains was really beyond my capabilities. With frequent stops and lots of encouragement from my son, I did it.  I had to. He couldn’t exactly carry me back to the car! That day I felt as though I had beaten the post Covid muscle weakness and was on my way back to health.”

When I got Covid again this past March, the symptoms were pretty much the same as in August 2020, muscle aches and joint pain, being exhausted, feeling cold all the time and my lips were frequently blue. The only difference was this time I did not have headaches.  I was loaned an oximeter by a family member who is a nurse and I found it quite strange that my body temperature was always two degrees below normal even though I had fever-like symptoms of being cold and shivering.  The muscle aches were significant, as was the fatigue, but since these are also symptoms of Covid, I didn’t think much of it.  It was only when I began to develop symptoms that were not associated with Covid that I began to become concerned.  

Me at my youngest son’s wedding, June 3, 2022

Fast forward to the beginning of June which was my youngest son’s wedding. I was so very unwell, but avoided talking about it as I did not want to detract from the very special occasion.

I was experiencing joint pain and muscle aches, and chills that would come and go. I would frequently get bluish lips, and continued to have significant non-pitting edema in my legs and ankles, and was wearing compression stockings all the time — even at the wedding. Most pronounced was the debilitating fatigue.

The skin on my cheeks had become flaky and dry and despite trying multiple types of intense moisturizers, nothing helped. My mouth symptoms had progressed to the point that I found it difficult to say certain words when speaking because my tongue seemed too large for my mouth, and the salivary glands underneath my tongue were swollen.

The muscle weakness had progressed to the point where it was difficult for me to get up from a chair, or to get out of my car without pushing myself up with my hands. My eldest son was helping me get to and from the beach for the photos, and out of the car.  He thought it was me aging, and when I recently asked my other two sons, they assumed the same thing.  I was wondering if I had some form of “long-Covid,” but what got me starting to think that my symptoms had something to do with my thyroid was the very noticeable swelling in my face.

At my son’s wedding I looked like I did when I was 55 pounds heavier!

LEFT: March 5, 2017, RIGHT: June 3, 2022 at my youngest son’s wedding.

The photo on the left, above is what I looked like when I began my weight-lost journey on March 5, 2017. The photo on the right is what I looked like June 3, 2022, at my youngest son’s wedding. I look more or less the same in both pictures, but with a fifty pound difference in weight. 

I found out a few weeks later, I had hypothyroidism and was displaying many of the symptoms of myxedema. [I have written an article from a clinical perspective about the symptoms of hypothyroidism, which is posted here.]

While we do it unintentionally, we all judge by appearance, and “weight gain” is no different. If we see someone at one point in time, we form an opinion based on what we see.  If anyone would have bumped into me three months ago, it would have been reasonable for them to assume that I had gained back all the weight I had lost, and then some. But that wasn’t the case. 

But what causes the appearance of “weight gain,” without gaining significant amounts of weight? 

As I explain in this recent clinical post about hypothyroidism, the “puffiness” is due to the accumulation of mucin under the skin. Mucin is a glycoprotein (a protein with a side chain of carbohydrate known as hyaluronic acid) that is naturally produced in the skin. Under normal circumstances, hyaluronic acid binds water to collagen and traps the water under the skin, keeping it looking moist and plump, In fact, hyaluronic acid is injected into the skin by dermatologists to make aging skin appear younger. The problem in hypothyroidism is that an excess of mucin accumulates under the skin, giving it a “tight, waxy” swollen texture. (I would describe it as feeling like an over-inflated balloon). 

Below is a photo showing the change in appearance in my left leg from November 3, 2021 (left), to July 16, 2022 (middle), to August 26, 2022 (right).

The photo on the left was taken by me last November while I was doing some stretches. It was still on my phone in mid-July when I took a picture of the swelling in my lower legs and ankles caused by mucin accumulating in the skin. The photo on the right was taken this morning, and while much of the swelling has been reduced, I am still unable to pinch any skin on my legs due to the remaining mucin. I have read that it can take 6 – 8 months for this to resolve.

I want people to understand that the appearance of “weight gain” and “weight loss” in hypothyroidism is different than weight gain and weight loss due to dietary changes. The difference, however can be very subtle.

In my case, the appearance of “weight gain” occurred very slowly.

My appearance between March 5, 2021 and exactly a year later are almost indistinguishable. It is only in retrospect, that I can see the puffiness in my face and legs. At the time, I was puzzled why my clothes fit tighter when there was only a 5 pound difference in my weight, but beyond that I didn’t give it any thought.

Below is a composite photo to help illustrate how slowly my appearance changed at first, and how quickly it progressed as my thyroid disorder progressed. Look how rapidly my appearance changed in only three months, between March 5, 2022, and my son’s wedding on June 3, 2022! 

[NOTE: As I’ve mentioned in all of my previous articles and posts about hypothyroidism, each person will present with different symptoms, and even those with the same symptoms may have very different appearance because of differences in their thyroid dysfunction.  Keep in mind, these photos describe only my own experience.]

Below is a composite photo to illustrate how quickly the appearance on my my face has resolved after only two months of thyroid treatment.

[NOTE: Again, this is my experience and each person’s will be different, depending on the nature of their thyroid dysfunction, as well as the type, timing and dosage of treatment their doctor prescribes.]

Last two photos are only 2 months after beginning thyroid treatment
I understand “regular” weight gain and the “weight gain” that often goes with hypothyroidism from both sides of the clinical desk.

An Expanded Perspective

My clinical practice changed 5 years ago when I came to understand what hyperinsulinemia was, and how early clinical signs of developing type 2 diabetes are evident as long as 20 years before diagnosis. In a similar way, my clinical practice is changing again now as the result of what I am learning about hypothyroidism.

Understanding the wide range of clinical and subclinical symptoms that people may have leads me to ask additional questions, to look at lab test results differently, and to ask for additional ones if it seems clinical warranted. While it is beyond the scope of practice of a Dietitian to diagnose any disease or to treat hypothyroidism, I am more aware of what to look and this helps me to refer people back to their doctor if I feel there may be a clinical concern.

Final Thoughts…

We form an opinion about someone’s appearance when we haven’t seen them in a while or when we meet them for the first time. While we do so unintentionally, in developing that opinion, we judge by appearance but sometimes the appearance of “weight gain” is not about diet, but about a diagnosis.

If anyone had seen me three months ago after not seeing me in a while, they might have assumed that I had gained back all the weight I had lost.

When we encounter someone who is overweight, we ought to bear in mind that don’t know where they are on their journey. We don’t know if they have metabolic issues related to glucose and insulin metabolism, are struggling with food addiction, or have an endocrine dysfunction, like hypothyroidism, or something else.

photos taken less than 3 months apart

People seeing me now have no idea that less than three months ago I looked as I did on the left, and was very ill.

As much as it is natural for all of us to form an opinion, let’s try not to let that opinion become a judgement.  Listening is a great way to find out more.

To your good health!

Joy

 

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

Measure of Health With a New Diagnosis – a Dietitian’s Journey

This article is the second entry in A Dietitian’s Journey Part II, which began with my recent diagnosis of hypothyroidism. The first entry in Part II was written last Friday, and you can find it here. This article is about how the factors by which I measure health have changed due to my diagnosis.

NOTE: Articles posted under A Dietitian’s  Journey are separate from referenced clinical articles (categorized as Science Made Simple articles) because these are about what happened to me (i.e., anecdotal) and based on my personal observation.

DISCLAIMER: The information in this post should not be taken as a recommendation to self-diagnose, self-interpret diagnostic tests, or self-treat any suspected disorder. It is essential that people who suspect they may have symptoms of any condition consult with their doctor, as only a medical doctor can diagnose and treat.

A Dietitian’s Journey – Part I

“A Dietitian’s Journey” was my personal weight-loss and health-recovery journey that began on March 5, 2017 when I decided to make dietary and lifestyle changes so that I could reclaim my health. At that time, I was obese, had type 2 diabetes for the previous 8 years, and extremely high blood pressure.  I achieved my goal two years later, on March 5, 2019. In retrospect, I realize why it took a year longer than I anticipated.  It is because I had high TSH levels, almost out of range. I had borderline subclinical hypothyroidism.

I believe that you can’t achieve a goal you don’t set“.  In other words, I accomplished my health goals the last time, because I set them. As the popular expression goes, “A goal without a plan is a wish.”

I also believe that success needs to measurable — that is the “m” in SMART goals (specific, measurable,  achievable,  relevant /realistic and timely.)  Before I began of Part I of A Dietitian’s Journey, I not only set my goals, I asked myself “what will success look like” which helped me define how I would measure success.

I wanted to achieve a normal body weight, be in remission of both type 2 diabetes and hypertension (high blood pressure).

Two years later, on March 5, 2019, I accomplished all but one of my goals, and the last one I achieve 3 months later. I lost:

    • 55 pounds
    • 12- 1/2 inches off my waist
    • 3 -1/2 inches off my chest
    • 6 -1/2 inches off my neck
    • 4 inches off each arm
    • 2- 1/2 inches off each thigh
    • I met the criteria for partial remission of type 2 diabetes 3 months earlier
    • my blood pressure still ranged between normal and pre-hypertension

If you want to get an idea of what I actually looked like at the beginning and at the end, there are two short videos on my Two Year Anniversary post that tell the story well.  The first video was taken when I started my journey, and it is very apparent how obese I was, and how difficult it was for me to walk and talk at the same time. The second clip was taken when I completed my journey and the difference is unmistakable.  

After recovering from Covid, I began hiking, and posted this encouraging “mountain top experience” post as my 5-year update. That was the pinnacle of recovering my heath. 

Except for the 19 pounds (my “Covid-19”) that I gained over the past 2 years, my weight has been stable. I continued to remain in partial remission of type 2 diabetes, and my blood pressure was normal until this past December.  In retrospect, that is when my health began to change. 

A Dietitian’s Journey – Part II

As told in last week’s post which was the first entry in Part II of A Dietitian’s Journey), things didn’t go as planned. Here is an excerpt from that post;

“Despite having had both vaccines (April 2021, July 2021), in March of 2022, I came down with what my doctor assumed was Covid again. At first, the symptoms were pretty much the same as in August 2020, muscle aches and joint pain, being exhausted, feeling cold all the time and my lips were frequently blue, but I did not have a headache.  I was loaned an oximeter by a family member who is a nurse and I found it quite strange that my body temperature was always two degrees below normal even though I had fever-like symptoms of being cold and shivering.  The muscle aches were significant, as was the fatigue, but since these are also symptoms of Covid, I didn’t think much of it.  It was only when I began to develop symptoms that were not associated with Covid that I began to become concerned.”

When I saw my doctor last Friday, he thought that it was very likely I had hypothyroidism, but wanted to run some lab tests to rule out any other possibilities.  I went to the lab last Monday morning, and my results came back late in the day. The ones I was waiting for showed exactly what both my doctor and I expected they would based on the supplements I had been taking prior to seeing him.  What I didn’t expect was that my blood sugar would indicate that I was no longer in partial remission of type 2 diabetes.  My blood pressure was higher than it had been in many years in his office, so I began taking it several times a day to see if it was “white coat syndrome” or genuinely high.  Unfortunately, it was the latter.  I knew what I had to do.  I sent him a fax, reported my blood pressure readings, and asked if he thought it was warranted, that he call in a prescription for the same medication I was on 4 years ago.

Last week I did quite a bit of research in the literature to better understand how low thyroid hormones could contribute to my high blood sugar and high blood pressure  — despite me continuing to eat a low carb diet. I wrote this referenced article on the blog of my long standing clinical practice about the metabolic changes that occur due to hypothyroidism. It is about how thyroid hormones act on every organ system in the body, and as a result when someone has hypothyroidism, there is a slowing of metabolism, which results in weight gain, high cholesterol, high blood sugar and high blood pressure.  Now it was making sense.

I now understood how over a period of three months (March 5, 2022 – June 3,2022) I went from looking as I have the last 5 years to looking as I did 55 pounds heavier.

TOP: 8 photos showing weight loss over 2 YEARS (March 5, 2017- March 5, 2019) BOTTOM: Changes in my appearance over 5 MONTHS (March 5, 2022- Aug 8, 2022)

I knew one of the symptoms of hypothyroidism was “weight gain,” but I had no idea that it could occur over such a short time frame!

Two months ago at my youngest son’s wedding, I looked like I did when I was 55 pounds heavier!

As described in last week’s post, I was very sick but it was devastating to look  like I did!

Today my appearance is almost back to normal. [August 24, 2022: see updated picture below]

Sometimes we have to look beyond what something looks like to the timeframe over which it occurred.

Following Up With my Doctor

Today I had my follow-up appointment with my doctor where we reviewed my lab test results from last week, and discussed next steps. My doctor requisitioned a free T4 test to see how my body is responding to the thyroid hormone treatment that he is overseeing.  He also gave me a requisition for a Thyroid Peroxidase antibody (TPO) test to find out if I have Hashimoto’s disease or if my hypothyroidism is due to my past thyroid surgery for a benign tumour. This article from my long-standing dietetic practice explains what these are.

Since Hashimoto’s is an autoimmune disease, how I would choose to approach my diet if the results of that test are positive would be different than if it comes back negative. 

I should have the results back tomorrow or Monday, but in the meantime, I am thinking about what I will do to recover my health once again, and how I will measure my success.

Once again, I am asking myself “what does success look like,” but this time it is in the context of this new diagnosis.

From what I have read, it is possible for my blood sugar and blood pressure to return to normal once the doctor adjusts my thyroid hormone replacement to its optimal dose, however for this goal to be “measurable” I need to have a better idea of how long this could take. 

A Dietitian’s Journey continues…

To your good health,

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

 

UPDATE (August 19, 2022) – terrific news!  I do not have TPO antibodies AND my fT4 is almost half way through the normal range. According to an April 25, 2021 webinar given by Endocrinologist Dr. Theodore Freidman, MD, PhD titled “Updates on Treating Hypothyroidism”, it is normal and expected for fT4 to be slightly lower given the type of thyroid hormone replacement that my doctor is overseeing.

[Put in plain English, this means I am the best kind of sick and the amount of medication I am currently taking is pretty close to optimal.]

I would have thought that not having antibodies meant that I didn’t have Hashimoto’s, but rather another type of primary hypothyroidism due to my past thyroid surgery (which is still a possibility).  I was wrong. Not all people with Hashimoto’s have measurable TPO antibodies!

It was previously thought that 5% of people diagnosed with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis have serum-negative thyroiditis, which is where they do not have measurable TPO  antibodies (TPO-ab) and ~50% don’t have positive thyroglobulin (Tg-ab) antibodies, either [1]. People with serum-negative thyroiditis are diagnosed with Hashimoto’s based on clinical presentation, or by ultrasound appearance.

An updated study from 2020 indicates that the percentage of people Hashimoto’s with serum-negative thyroiditis is 20.8%, not 5% as previously thought. It is very encouraging that in subsequent follow-up only ~16% of those with SN-CAT eventually developed positive antibody tests for TPO-Ab and/or Tg-Ab [2].

In my opinion, in terms of a diagnosis of hypothyroidism, this is the best I could have hoped for. It is does not appear to be the autoimmune type (although Tg-ab antibodies weren’t tested, they are only positive in half of those with Hashimoto’s).

Based on this new study, there is a low likelihood of me going on to develop thyroid antibodies especially since I have no family history of autoimmune disorders!

I will take my time and read through the literature and then in light of these results determine what dietary changes I will make.  Now that I know my fT4 is just about optimal, I will determine how I will measure success in terms of my restored health in the day’s ahead.

To your (and my!) good health!

Joy

References

  1.  Rotondi M et al. Serum negative autoimmune thyroiditis displays a milder clinical picture compared with classic Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. Eur J Endocrinol 2014;171:31-6. Epub April 17 2014
  2. Croce, L., De Martinis, L., Pinto, S. et al. Compared with classic Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, chronic autoimmune serum-negative thyroiditis requires a lower substitution dose of L-thyroxine to correct hypothyroidism. J Endocrinol Invest 43, 1631–1636 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40618-020-01249-x

 

UPDATE (August 24, 2022)It has been exactly 2 ½ months since my son’s wedding and 2 months since I began thyroid replacement medication and I am feeling quite a bit better about the image I see in the mirror. The change is more subtle this week, but I see less swelling in the cheeks. It will take a few more months for the less seen parts of my body to recover, but I am feeling hopeful.

 

 

 

 

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

 

When a New Diagnosis is a Long Time Coming

Three weeks ago, I wrote an article for my long-standing dietetic practice (BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)  about how a diagnosis of hypothyroidism is made and why it takes until someone has been unwell for quite a while before they are finally diagnosed. In one sense, that article laid the foundation for this one, and in another sense this article is the most recent update of my personal weight and health-recovery story (A Dietitian’s Journey).

DISCLAIMER(August 14, 2022): This article a personal account posted under A Dietitian’s Journey. The information in this post should in no way be taken as a recommendation to self-diagnose, self-interpret diagnostic tests, or self-treat any suspected disorder. It is essential that people who suspect they may have symptoms of any condition consult with their doctor, as only a medical doctor can diagnose and treat.


Two years ago, in the summer of 2019, I was feeling fantastic and was in remission of type 2 diabetes and hypertension and was celebrating my “little black dress moment.”

In August 2020, I had what my doctor assumed was Covid (back pain, non-stop headache, and couldn’t stop shivering) and since at that point the line up for a nasal swab was 6 hours long due to one of the testing sites closing, my doctor recommended that I simply assume I was positive, and self-isolate for two weeks, which I did.

For many weeks afterwards, I had overall muscle pain and weakness, as well as tingling and numbness in my fingertips, what is referred to as “brain fog”, and unbelievable fatigue. I went from being reasonably active and fit in the spring, to finding it difficult to even walk up or down a flight of stairs by August. Covid was new at that point, so none of us knew what to expect, but it took months until I began to feel reasonably normal. I learned to live with the muscle aches, joint pain, ‘brain fog’, and fatigue. The joint pain persisted for a long time, and was assumed to be post-viral arthritis as I had this once before when I had rubella as an adult.

Despite having had both vaccines (April 2021, July 2021), in March of 2022, I came down with what my doctor assumed was Covid again. At first, the symptoms were pretty much the same as in August 2020, muscle aches and joint pain, being exhausted, feeling cold all the time and my lips were frequently blue, but I did not have a headache.  I was loaned an oximeter by a family member who is a nurse and I found it quite strange that my body temperature was always two degrees below normal even though I had fever-like symptoms of being cold and shivering.  The muscle aches were significant, as was the fatigue, but since these are also symptoms of Covid, I didn’t think much of it.  It was only when I began to develop symptoms that were not associated with Covid that I began to become concerned.  One of those symptoms was non-pitting edema in my lower legs and feet, and I don’t mean just a little bit of swelling. Below is a picture of before, and during;

I ordered compression stockings on-line and wore them daily to help keep the swelling down, but carried on working and writing the book, even though I was very tired all the time. I also began to have a very weird sensation in my mouth – my tongue became enlarged, and the salivary glands under my tongue were swollen. Since both of these affected my sense of taste, I thought this may be related to Covid, but then it progressed to the point where I found it difficult to talk properly because my tongue seemed too big for my mouth. I also began losing hair, but this had occurred several years ago, too.  At the time, my TSH was “in the normal range”, so no further testing was done (see this article to know why TSH alone is not good indicator of hypothyroidism, especially when it is at the high end of the normal range, which mine was).  In retrospect, the subclinical problem with my thyroid has been going on quite a while. Sometimes it would be worse than others, which is not unusual.

Fast forward to two months ago (beginning of June), which was my youngest son’s wedding. I was still experiencing fatigue and muscle aches, chills that would come and go, would get bluish lips, and continued to have significant (non-pitting) edema in my legs and ankles, and was wearing compression stockings all the time — even at the wedding. The skin on my cheeks had become flaky and dry and despite trying multiple types of intense moisturizers, nothing helped. My mouth symptoms had progressed to the point that I found it difficult to say certain words when speaking with my clients because my tongue seemed too large for my mouth, and the salivary glands underneath my tongue were swollen. I continued to have overall muscle aches and weakness, but it had slowly progressed to the point where it was difficult for me to get up from a chair, or to get out of my car without pushing myself up with my hands.  I was wondering if I had some form of “long-Covid,” but what got me starting to think that my symptoms had something to do with my thyroid was the very noticeable swelling in my face. At my son’s wedding I looked like I did when I was 55 pounds heavier, but without significant weight gain.

After doing some reading in the scientific literature, as well as chatting with a couple of functional medicine doctors, I began to think that my symptoms were consistent with hypothyroidism.  In addition, I knew that when I was in my early 20s I had a benign tumour removed from the isthmus of my thyroid and as part of the pre-surgery work up, I had an x-ray that required me to drink radioactive iodine. It wasn’t known at the time but it is known now that both the surgery on the thyroid (even though it remains largely intact), as well as the exposure to high doses of radioactive iodine can initiate a process that can lead to hypothyroidism years later.

It is also apparently possible that having had Covid back in 2020 may have initiated it and/or it may have been initiated as a response to the having the vaccines. I am not blaming either the virus or the vaccines because my thyroid surgery and exposure to high doses of radioactive iodine predated this by decades, but they may have been the precipitating event to symptoms.  It is also possible that symptoms would have started on their own simply as a result of age.

I knew I was unwell and needed to see my doctor in person. After my son’s wedding, I called his office and wanted to go in and have him assess me for hypothyroidism, but he was out of town. Instead of meeting with the locum, I decided to wait until he was back. In the meantime I began using some supplements that are involved in thyroid metabolism, such as kept (for iodine), selenium and some other nutrients and while they helped a little bit, it was not significant. After doing a great deal of reading in the literature and listening to several medical presentations by a well-known endocrinologist and professor of medicine from the US, I decided while waiting to see my doctor that I would try using a very small amounts of another type of supplement to see if it made any difference in my symptoms. I introduced it at half the rate and half of the dose usually used because (1) I had not yet seen my doctor (was not under medical supervision yet) and (2) I was aware that use of this supplement was not something to be taken lightly as it can cause problems for older individuals, or those with heart disease (which I don’t have). 

This morning I saw my doctor for the first time since Covid began. I had sent him a fax last week outlining the ways I had improved because I knew it was too much information for a 10 minute visit. I explained that I was feeling significantly better. My face swelling had gone down a great deal, the edema in my legs had almost disappeared – to the point that I could walk around bare-legged in the excessive heat we had last week with NO swelling what-so-ever. The skin on my legs is still very tight and shiny, but no edema. I lost 5-6 pounds of water-weight (face, legs and abdomen) and most noticeable, the muscle weakness is gone!  I could walk up and downstairs, carry heavy parcels, and can get up from a chair or out of my car with ease.  I also explained in the fax that I rarely feel cold, but still have occasional blue lips and chills late in the afternoon, but that from what I’ve read in the literature, many people do better on the same amount split over 3 doses, rather than two. 

When my doctor entered the examining room, he said he had just re-read the fax and based on what I wrote, he thinks it is very likely that I have hypothyroidism, but he wants to rule out other things that could look like it and aren’t, or that mimic it. He wasn’t in a rush, like he usually is. He looked at the pictures I had on my phone —ones I had taken of my legs, my tongue, my face. When he saw the picture of me two months ago at my youngest son’s wedding, he simply said “oh my.” He then gave me a very thorough examination.  He palpitated my thyroid and listened for a long time to my heart and lungs.  After examining me, he pointed out several other physical symptoms that I have that are quite consistent with hypothyroidism, and said “Joy, I think your conclusion is right on.” I was somewhere between shocked and elated.

My doctor then brought up my past lab work on his screen and remarked that my TSH has been “high normal” since 2013 (see below), and that I often had low ferritin with no explanation, as well as past “unexplained” issues with hair loss.  I had nine years with subclinical symptoms but no testing could be done because as indicated on the lab test results below “The free T4 was cancelled. The protocol recommends no further testing.

TSH – 2013 – “in normal range”
TSG – 2015 – “in normal range”

I mentioned to him that I wondered what the results would have shown if my T3 or T4 were tested in 2013, or 2015, when my TSH was high-normal. He replied “unfortunately, unless someone has clear symptoms that are consistent with hypothyroidism there is nothing we can do, but your symptoms are very consistent now, but I think this diagnosis was a long time coming.” Surprisingly, we saw eye to eye.

I think my doctor realized that the guidelines being as they are means that people like me have to get quite unwell before they are finally diagnosed and treated.  I realized that his hands were effectively tied by a system that will not enable him to test T3 or T4 even with high-normal TSH, without overt symptoms. He could do nothing until I got much sicker. 

I was delighted by his response. He has been my doctor for 20 years and was not receptive to my use of a low carb and then a ketogenic diet to put my type 2 diabetes into remission, and previously refused twice to test my fasting insulin, along with my fasting blood glucose.  Today he was very different.

When I asked if he was going to refer me back to the endocrinologist I used to see when I was diabetic and have her manage my thyroid replacement medication and he said “No. I don’t believe in changing something that is clearly working. I want you to keep taking what you’re taking in the same amount you are now, and I am going to run some lab work to see if you have gotten the amount right. We may need to increase it a little or change the timing to address the late afternoon chills, but no, I’m not going to “fix” something that is no longer broken.” He even agreed to add a fasting insulin test, without any protest!

I don’t know what happened to make my doctor change his mind and how he approaches these types of matters, but today I said to him that it has been a long time since I was this delighted with his approach, and that I am very thankful that he is my doctor because he practices good medicine. I offered him my hand and he shook it warmly and thanked me.

I guess if I can change how I practice dietetics based on new evidence, so can my doctor — or your doctor.  Don’t give up, or be hesitant to have those difficult conversations with your primary care physician. We need them to oversee our care, and maybe just maybe in the process of interacting with some patients, they learn something they didn’t before, or change because of things they see in their practice. The bottom line was that I needed my doctor to know what I was doing and to examine me and make sure I was not doing something that could cause me harm.  He not only rose to the occasion with grace, but responded in a manner I could have only dreamt of before.

I do not believe that self-treating is ever advisable, and certainly if it were not for Covid and my doctor not having in-person office hours unless it was an emergency, I  would have gone to see him months ago. I am glad I saw him today and am very thankful that he is being so supportive.

I know once we get the levels of thyroid hormones right, that losing the 20 pounds I gained over the pandemic will be possible, but in the meantime, it is no small matter that I got my life back!!

A Dietitian’s Journey continues…

To your good health,

Joy

I don’t post the comparison picture below easily. It is very hard for me to see how bad I looked, but it is important to see just like the leg pictures, above. The photo on the right was taken at my youngest son’s wedding, June 3, 2022 (exactly 2 months ago) at the height of my hypothyroid symptoms.  The photo on the left is a selfie I took today, August 5, 2022, almost exactly two months later. There is still swelling in my face and legs to come down, but any adjustment in thyroid meds only be done after the upcoming lab work.

LEFT: August 5, 2022, RIGHT: July 3, 2022 (2 months apart)

 


NOTE (August 15, 2022): It is important to keep in mind that too little, or too much thyroid hormone can have serious consequences.

Untreated or under-treated hypothyroidism can be serious and is when the body gets too little thyroid hormone. This can lead to a myxedema crisis (covered in this article).

Thyrotoxicosis can also be serious and is when the body gets too much thyroid hormone. This can occur in untreated hyperthyroidism, or by self-treating hypothyroidism (covered in this article).

If you suspect you may have hypothyroidism (or any other clinical condition), consult with your doctor, and “don’t try this at home.”

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

 

FREE 27-page Download with Sample Recipe

Finally, there are low-carb breads made without nut flour, cheese, or beaten egg whites, and that contains no psyllium, chia seed, xanthan gum, guar gum, or inulin which cause many people digestive issues. These are “real breads that happen to be low carb.”

Click on the green button below to get a FREE 27-page booklet that explains the essentials about this new category of homemade low-carb breads and includes the “game changer” that led to the development of the others.

FREE 27-PAGE DOWNLOAD

This 27-page
FREE DOWNLOAD
includes the
“game changer” recipe

that led to the development
of all the other recipes.

Click on the free download button to get yours.


Looking for something shorter that you can print out?

FREE 1-PAGE DOWNLOAD

Click on the purple button below to get a FREE 1-page printable download about this new category of low carb breads that are made with NO nut flours, psyllium, chia seed, xanthan or guar gum, or inulin.

 

About My Book – Low Carb Breads of the World

I never planned to write a low carb bread book, but it came about due to both interest and need.  Beginning in September 2021, I began to experiment with low carb breads that were not made from nut flour. By mid-December I was finally successful and posted the recipe for Low Carb High Protein Yeast Bread, and this bread turned out to be a “game changer”.  It was what I called “real bread that happens to be low carb.” But, most impressive were the macros! Each slice of Low Carb High Protein Yeast Bread had only 1.6g net carbs and 11.4 g protein. I knew I was onto something.

The ingredient that made this first ‘real bread’ possible was vital wheat gluten, which is not wheat flour but one of several types of wheat protein isolate. Wheat protein isolate is to wheat, what whey protein isolate is to dairy, and both are proteins that have been used in food production and as a protein supplement. This ingredient gives bread its distinct “pully” texture and makes bread different from cake or pastry. Discovering this and other low-carb ingredients resulted in me re-visiting my old hobby of bread baking – something I did over the previous 35 years before adopting a low carb diet in March 2017.

After posting the recipe for Low Carb High Protein Yeast Bread in mid-December 2021, I began to have people contact me on social media to request that I bake the breads and ship them to them. One person wanted me to courier them several loaves, and I had to explain that I am a Dietitian in full-time private practice and had no time to bake bread as a sideline. A few people tried to convince me to open a low-carb bakery (which I also had no interest in), and then some said I should write a cookbook featuring recipes for these low-carb bread. I mentioned this to one of my young adult sons, who thought I should consider the idea. Without really thinking it through, I created a Twitter poll asking who would be interested in such a book and then asked the same question on Facebook and Instagram. The responses were overwhelmingly in favor, so the following morning, I looked at my young adult son and said, “it looks like I am writing a low-carb bread book.”

And so, it began…

The recipes in this book form a completely different category of low-carb bread. They contain no nut or seed flour, and while cheese and egg may be included as ingredients in a recipe, they do not form the basis of the bread. In addition, these bread contain no psyllium, chia seed, xanthan gum, guar gum, or inulin, as these ingredients often cause digestive issues. As a result, Low Carb Breads of the World may remove unnecessary barriers that people currently have to adopt a low-carb lifestyle. This book makes culturally appropriate and ingredient-appropriate bread available to people from bread-centric cultures with high rates of type 2 diabetes, including Southeast Asian and Hispanic.

Low Carb Breads of the World is more than a cookbook or a collection of recipes. It introduces novel ingredients for baking low-carb bread and explains how to use them successfully in different types of recipes.  The recipes provide an opportunity to utilize the ingredients and the methods to produce a variety of breads of the world. These recipes are not perfect replicas of the high-carb originals but are as close as I was able to get them using readily available low-carb ingredients with minimal allergens or ingredients that cause digestive issues.

I hope that people from a wide range of backgrounds will apply the information in my book to create low-carb versions of bread central to their cultures, thereby making a low-carb diet accessible to those who would not have otherwise considered it.

While I never set out to write a low-carb bread book, I realize that this book will do what I do in my private practice: help people pursue a healthier lifestyle.

You can click on the “free download” button below to get a FREE 27-page booklet that explains the essentials about this new category of homemade low-carb breads and includes the “game changer” that led to the development of the others.

To your good health!

Joy Y. Kiddie MSc, RD

 

FREE DOWNLOAD

 

Includes the “game changer” recipe that led to the development of all the others.

Click on the free download button below to get your FREE 27-page booklet with recipe.

 

Why I Changed My Mind About Low Carb Bread

I have been supporting people in following a low‐carb and keto lifestyle for the past five years, but until recently, I was not in favor of low‐carb bread. The reason was that there were only a few low‐carb or keto bread options, and each had its drawbacks.

Most low‐carb bread is made from nut flours such as almond flour and coconut
flour, with or without adding different types of cheese (such as so‐called
“fathead” pizza).

While these breads work well for some people, the extra energy intake provided by the nuts and cheese often made weight loss more difficult, especially for peri and post‐menopausal women.

While bread made from whipped egg white provides a high protein, low‐fat, low carb bread option, the texture of this protein‐sparing bread is often disliked.

The lack of acceptable low‐carb bread options posed a problem for me as a Dietitian. While some people are fine using lettuce to wrap a burger in, lettuce wraps do not address the needs of people from bread‐centric cultures. People of South Asian (Indian) descent have approximately 6x higher rates of type 2 diabetes than the general population and I came to realize that it was essential
for them to have culturally appropriate low‐carb bread such as chapati/roti,
paratha, and naan.

With rates of type 2 diabetes being almost double in the Hispanic population, low‐carb corn‐style and flour‐style tortillas were also important. While these could be made using nut flours and gums such as xanthan gum, guar gum, or psyllium to make them flexible, these ingredients often cause digestive issues.

In addition to people’s cultural needs, there was also the fact that many people have nut allergies which makes most low‐carb bread options made with almond flour unavailable. A similar issue exists for those allergic to eggs ‐‐ making egg white‐based bread such as ‘cloud bread’ or protein‐sparing bread unavailable as low‐carb options.

In late October 2021, I saw a protein bread imported from Germany that was like the classic Vollkornbrot bread but made from some unique ingredients.

This bread had more than three times the protein of this company’s whole‐meal rye bread and more than 80% fewer carbohydrates, so I bought it to try. It was heavy and dense and tasted good, but at almost 50 cents per slice, I thought, “this can’t be that hard to make.”

I ordered some of the ingredients online and began experimenting with making low carbohydrate, yeast‐risen, high‐protein bread that contained no beaten egg white, no nut flours, and no cheese. It took quite a few attempts until I made a successful bread, but I persisted, and on December 14, 2021, I posted the recipe for Low Carb High Protein Yeast Bread. This bread turned out to be a “gamechanger.” It was “real bread that happened to be low carb.”

Most impressive were the macros! Each slice of Low Carb High Protein Yeast
Bread had only 1.6 g net carbs and 11.4 g protein.

Even with ordering all the ingredients online from Canada, compared to commercial Carbonaught® Multigrain Bread that weighed the same (544 g), it cost 35% less.

Most ingredients are available in regular supermarkets in the US, and no matter where in the world people live, like me, they could order these ingredients online and bake these low‐carb bread themselves. I knew I was onto something.

The ingredient that made this first ‘real bread’ possible was ‘vital wheat gluten,’ which is not wheat flour but one of several types of wheat protein isolate. Wheat protein isolate is to wheat, what whey protein isolate is to dairy, and both are proteins that have been used in food production and as a protein supplement. I later found out that there are several different types of wheat isolates. Vital wheat gluten is a protein isolate of gliadin and glutenin separated from the wheat starch (where all the carbs are) and other grain components. Gliadin and glutenin give bread its distinct “pully” texture and make bread different from cake or pastry. Just as adding vital wheat gluten gives bread its characteristic texture, the inclusion of whey protein gives low carb bread its crisp, brown crust.

Discovering these low‐carb ingredients resulted in me re‐visiting my old hobby of bread baking – something I did over the previous 35 years before adopting a low carb diet in March 2017. Most of my low‐carb breads began as recipes for regular high‐carb bread that are hand‐written on recipe cards and fill one of the multiple recipe boxes.

It was vital wheat gluten that made other breads possible – from crusty sandwich loaves, brioche, buns and rolls to culturally acceptable low‐carb versions of chapati/roti, paratha, naan, and corn‐style and flour‐style tortillas.


As Dietitian it was finally possible to offer those from a South Asian or Hispanic background culturally appropriate low‐carb breads they could make at home, enabling them to adopt a low‐carb diet to help improve their health. In addition, these ingredients meant that those with nut allergies could have low‐carb bread without having to resort to egg‐white bread and since many of these breads do not contain eggs, there are low‐carb bread alternatives for those with egg allergies.

After posting photos of some of these early breads on social media, people kept asking me for the recipes. Some wanted to commission me to make these breads and courier them to them regularly, but I am a Dietitian in full‐time clinical practice with no desire to open a baking business. When someone suggested I write a book, I was initially resistant to the idea; however, it was evident that there was both an interest and a need.

In January 2021, I decided to write Low Carb Breads of the World because it provided a much‐needed dietary option to many people. The breads contain no nut flours. They have no psyllium, xanthan gum, guar gum, or inulin, as these ingredients cause many people digestive issues, and many of the breads in the book are made without eggs or dairy. These breads are not perfect replicas of the original but are as close as possible using low‐carb ingredients that are readily available and with minimal priority allergens. They are real breads that happen to be low carb.

Low Carb Breads of the World is not just a cookbook or a collection of recipes. Instead, it introduces low‐carb ingredients and explains how to use them for baking several different types of low‐carb bread. The recipes in the book provide an opportunity to utilize the ingredients and the methods to produce a variety of breads of the world. By understanding the science behind using these ingredients, people will begin to be able to adapt their traditional bread recipes to be low carb, and that is ultimately the goal of the book.

Like the expression “give a man a fish, you feed him for a day, teach a many to
fish, you feed him for a lifetime,” this book is intended to teach people what is
needed so they can apply that knowledge to make the breads they grew up on
and love, low carb.

For those who can eat and enjoy nut‐flour and egg‐based low carb bread, these are an excellent option, but for those for whom they are not suitable, there is another choice.

To your good health!

Joy

 


Joy Kiddie is a Registered Dietitian with a master’s degree in human nutrition from the University of British Columbia (Canada). She has been providing low‐carb and keto services since 2015 through her long‐standing dietetic practice BetterByDesign Nutrition (www.bbdnutrition.com) and since 2017 has been supporting people through her dedicated low‐carb division, The Low Carb Healthy Fat Dietitian (www.lchf‐rd.com). Joy helps people reduce their hunger and food cravings to achieve their weight loss goals and improve their metabolic health. She is also the author of the upcoming book, Low Carb Breads of the World.

 

You can download a copy of this article here.

ADA Releases a Low and Very Low Carb Guide for Health Care Providers

The American Diabetes Association (ADA) has released a 28-page guide for Health Care providers on implementing low-carbohydrate (LC) and very low-carbohydrate (VLC) eating patterns to improve outcomes in adults with type 2 diabetes. The purpose of the Guide is to assist Health Care Providers, including Physicians, Registered Dietitians, certified diabetes care & education specialists (CDCES), and others, to assess whether these interventions would be appropriate for their patients and if so, how to best implement them.

The Guide is authored by Kelly Siverhus MS, RD, CD, and several advisors. These include three American Diabetes Association Dietitians, five expert advisors including 4 Registered Dietitians and an MD, and a Registered Dietitian primary advisor from Diabetes and Nutrition Consultants. One of the four expert Advisors was Dawn Noe, RD, LD, CDCES, who gave a presentation on Person-Centered Implementation of Low Carbohydrate Eating Plans at the American Association of Diabetes Educators (AADEs) annual conference in Houston, Texas, in August 2019. She graciously shared her slides with me for this article.

This new Guide is the culmination of several American Diabetes Association position statements, a consensus report, and several Standards of Medical Care in Diabetes (2019, 2020) publications which included the use of both a low carbohydrate and very low carbohydrate (ketogenic) diet.

Low Carbohydrate and Very Low Carbohydrate Eating Patterns in Adults with Diabetes: A Guide for Health Care Providers

This 28-page guide includes information on

    • Potential Benefits
    • Indications and Contraindications
    • Determining and Reassessing a Carbohydrate Goal
    • Tools and Strategies for Eating Pattern Education, including what to emphasize
    • A 10-page section (pages 16-26) with Resources for Patient Education, including
      • Food Lists for Low Carbohydrate Meal Planning
      • Getting Started
      • Low Carbohydrate Starch Alternatives
      • Low Carbohydrate Plate Method
      • Sample Meal Plans (Structured)
      • Sample Meal Plans (Build your Own)
    • References

The Guide is an excellent resource for Health Care Providers to help them assess the appropriateness of a low-carbohydrate (LC) or very-low-carbohydrate (VLC) diet for any given patient and provides good explanations of the different approaches that can be taken. In addition, the 10-page Resources for Patient Education provide strategies and sample meal plans for implementing a low carb or very low carb eating pattern, along with the necessary details to assist a wide range of Health Care Providers in supporting their patients in adopting a low carbohydrate or very low carbohydrate diet.

This Guide can be ordered directly from the ADA online shop for $8.95 USD.

Final Thoughts…

While nothing is “new” in this Guide, it is an excellent synthesis of information already contained in the American Diabetes Association’s 2018 Position Statements, 2019 Consensus Report, and Standards of Medical Care in Diabetes (2019, 2020). The Guide provides a convenient, evidence-based tool for US-based Health Care providers to use with their patients.

It is my sincere hope that Diabetes Canada might make something like this available for use by Canadian-based Health Care providers, including Physicians, Registered Dietitians, and certified diabetes care & education specialists.

More Info?

If you would like more information about how I can support you following a low carbohydrate of very low carbohydrate diet, please have a look under the Services tab, or send me a note through the Contact Me form.

To your good health!

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

 

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.

From the Mountains Through the Valleys – 5 year update

Tomorrow is March 5th and it is five years since I began my personal health and weight recovery journey that I’ve dubbed “A Dietitian’s Journey“.  While it began in 2017, in a way it still continues today and that is the point behind this post. 

March 2017

Five years ago, I was obese, had type 2 diabetes for the previous 8 years, and had developed dangerously high blood pressure. 

This picture is what I looked like then.  There is no mistaking that I was a very sick woman.

You can hear it in my voice in the video below. It is very apparent that I could barely walk and talk at the same time.

A year after I had adopted a low carbohydrate lifestyle (March 5, 2018), I had lost:

  • 32 pounds
  • 8 inches off my waist
  • 2 inches off my chest
  • 3 inches off my neck
  • 1 inch off my arms
  • 1/2 inch off my thighs
  • no longer meet the criteria for type 2 diabetes (achieved without the use of medication)
  • had blood pressure that ranges between normal and pre-hypertension without medication
  • had ideal triglycerides and excellent cholesterol levels achieved without any medication.
April 2017 – April 2019

Two years after beginning my journey I had lost a total of;

  • 55 pounds
  • 12- 1/2 inches off my waist
  • 3 -1/2 inches off my chest
  • 6 -1/2 inches off my neck
  • 4 inches off each arm
  • 2- 1/2 inches off each thigh
  • met the criteria for partial remission of type 2 diabetes
  • blood pressure still ranged between normal and pre-hypertension
  • had ideal triglycerides and excellent cholesterol levels
March 2020

On the third anniversary of beginning my journey, March 5, 2020, I remained at a normal body weight, had an optimal waist circumference (slightly less than half my height), and was still in remission of type two diabetes and high blood pressure.

I had gone from taking 12 different medications three years earlier, to being on one prescription for something non-metabolically related. I felt so good — so happy in my own skin that decided to stop straightening my hair, and began wearing it the way it grows out of my head.

March 5 2021 was 4 years from when I began my journey. Here is a short clip from a podcast I was on around that time. Listen to how different I sounded from the clip above.

Then I took up hiking! 

Four years earlier, I could barely walk and talk at the same time and for six months, I was hiking every week, or two.

This photo was taken last year on March 6, 2021 — the 4th anniversary of beginning my journey.

But like most journeys, this one has had ups and downs. There have been “mountain top experiences,” and “valleys,” and currently I am in a bit of a valley.

About two months ago, I was exposed to the Delta variant of Covid and while I didn’t get more than cold-like symptoms, once again my body responded to the exposure with post viral arthritis that I have had a twice since my late 20s.  The first time was after I contracted rubella as a young adult, and the second time was after having what was presumed to be Covid in August 2020 (covered in previous posts). Despite the overall joint pain, I was not going to let it get me down. I kept pushing myself — working on developing recipes for my upcoming book, Low Carb Breads of the World.

The joint pain has eased up quite a bit over the past few weeks, but there remained increasing discomfort at the base of my thumb on my right hand that kept getting worse. Last week it became unbearable.  I assumed that I had developed arthritis in the CMC joint of my thumb, but I found out this week that it is DeQuervain’s tenosynovitis that developed from the repetitive motion of kneading bread several times a week for long periods of time. This was an unfortunate by-product of working on recipe development for the low carb bread book.

Out of necessity, many of the things I was actively doing suddenly came to a halt. For the next 4-6 weeks I have to wear a brace 24-hour per day that splints my thumb and wrist, and enables it to heal.  It is discouraging, but there isn’t much I can do about it. I apply ice, do my physio, wear the brace and focus on looking ahead.

In a way, tomorrow being the 5th anniversary of my journey encourages me.

While not the “mountain top experience” of a year ago, even in this temporary “valley”, things are SO much better than they were 5 years ago.

While I haven’t managed to lose all the 20 pounds I had put on during Covid as I had planned to do, I also haven’t regained my weight, either. My blood sugars are still good, and so is my blood pressure and that is something I am very thankful for, and to celebrate.

Despite the ups and downs, I am still moving forward. I continue to eat low carb and have no desire to eat any other way. I am metabolically healthy and that is a lot to be thankful for.

While we all go through ups and downs, it is what we do day-to-day that really counts towards putting diseases like type 2 diabetes and hypertension into remission.

People ask me why I “still” eat this way and the answer is easy. If I go back to eating the way I did before, I will become “fat and sick” like I was before, too! No, thanks.

For me, there is no looking back — only forward. From the mountains to the valleys, I choose to remain low carb for my ongoing health. 

I hope my story and persistence encourages you.

To your good health!

Joy

You can follow me on:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/lchfRD
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lchfRD/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lchf_rd

Copyright ©2022 The LCHF Dietitian (a division of BetterByDesign Nutrition Ltd.)

LEGAL NOTICE: The contents of this blog, including text, images and cited statistics as well as all other material contained here (the ”content”) are for information purposes only.  The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your physician and regular monitoring by your physician. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your physician with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or before implementing anything  you have read or heard in our content.